The Impact of Threats on Global Shipping: Adaptive Supply Chains

Ongoing instability impacts shipping efficiency and has broader economic implications. These disruptions highlight the need for adaptive supply chain strategies and leveraging advanced technologies to navigate increased risks and operational costs.

Adobe Stock 912833569
Everything by Rachan/stock.adobe.com

The USS Dwight D. Eisenhower, a crucial aircraft carrier at the forefront of efforts to counter Houthi attacks in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, returned to the U.S. in June 2024 after a deployment of over seven months. Following the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel, this nuclear-powered carrier played a vital role in safeguarding commercial and military vessels from Iranian-backed Houthi threats.

Since January 2024, the increasing peril in the region has compelled hundreds of ships to circumvent the Red Sea, opting for the considerably longer route around Africa. This deviation results in adding over a week to each journey, leading to substantial hikes in costs and fuel consumption: Cargo spending 30% more time on the water means fuel consumption for the same routes also increases by 30%. Moreover, with longer sailing times, each vessel completes fewer estimated trips annually, consequently reducing fleet capacity by 23%. More ships are required to transport the same volume of goods, leading to increased costs and inefficiencies across the supply chain.

Houthi attacks, particularly those targeting shipping routes in the Red Sea and surrounding areas, have had several significant impacts on global ocean shipping:

1. Increased Security Risks:

  • Shipping lines that operate in or near conflict zones, such as the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait, face heightened security risks. This narrow passage is crucial for global trade, especially for oil shipments from the Middle East to Europe and North America. Houthi attacks have led to increased security measures, including rerouting of vessels, which can lead to longer transit times.

2. Rising Insurance Costs:

  • The increased risk of attacks has driven up insurance premiums for vessels transiting these waters. War risk insurance, in particular, has seen significant hikes, which in turn raises the overall cost of shipping goods through these regions.

3. Potential Delays:

  • Attacks or threats of attacks can cause delays as ships may be rerouted to avoid dangerous areas. Additionally, inspections and security checks might become more rigorous, further delaying the movement of goods.

4. Impact on Freight Rates:

  • The combination of longer routes, increased security measures, and higher insurance costs can push freight rates higher. This impact can ripple across global supply chains, particularly affecting goods that are sensitive to shipping costs, like oil and consumer goods.

5. Disruption of Trade Flows:

  • If attacks become frequent or severe enough, they could disrupt key trade flows, especially those involving energy products. For example, the Red Sea and Bab-el-Mandeb Strait are critical chokepoints for oil and gas shipments. Any significant disruption here can have a broader impact on global energy markets and related industries.

6. Political and Economic Instability:

  • Persistent threats in the region can exacerbate political and economic instability, further complicating trade. Companies might be reluctant to engage in trade routes that are considered high risk, leading to reduced traffic in the affected areas and potential shortages of goods in certain markets.

These impacts highlight the vulnerability of global shipping to geopolitical tensions and underscore the importance of maintaining secure and stable shipping routes.

The Dual Threats of Geopolitical Shifts and Targeted Disruption

The era of effortless globalization is clearly over. Global supply chains are increasingly susceptible to two types of disruptions.

The first is structural geopolitical shifts that reshape where and how goods are shipped. Unlike temporary route adjustments, these disruptions—such as escalating trade wars, physical conflicts and the rise of nationalism—fundamentally alter trade routes and partnerships.

For instance, nearshoring, punitive tariffs and sanctions on strategic goods, like advanced chips, are becoming more common, rendering once-stable trade lanes obsolete or even illegal. This leads to a constant and complex rewiring of the global supply chain, requiring duplication of infrastructure and raising costs for shippers, carriers and consumers alike.

The second type involves more immediate and discrete disruptions, such as the Houthi attacks in the Red Sea. These events not only lengthen or complicate shipping routes, but they can also completely halt them.

A related aspect of the Houthi campaign included allied Iraqi militants claiming responsibility for a drone attack on Eilat, Israel. The proliferation of low-cost drone technology has enabled small, underfunded groups to disrupt crucial transportation routes, even when routes are protected by naval forces like the Eisenhower. This trend is further accelerated by conflicts such as the war in Ukraine, where increasingly destructive drones are being developed from inexpensive commercial parts, tipping the balance in favor of guerrilla-style aggressors.

Manufacturers and shippers cannot control either of these disruptive events or the geopolitical forces behind them, but they are not powerless.

Leveraging New Technology for Resilient and Adaptive Supply Chains

Critics of a naval task force to protect commercial ships in the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden have been largely proven right: a defensive strategy alone is unlikely to deter attacks. Moreover, any direct military action risks escalating the conflict in the region to an uncontrollable level, potentially worsening an already precarious economic situation. To effectively manage these disruptions, it is essential to develop flexible and adaptable supply chains rather than rigid and brittle ones. But how?

The key to navigating these challenges is to fully leverage advances in supply chain management technology. Modern, adaptable systems can help connect the dots between ever-changing logistics, conflicts and regulatory landscapes, ensuring better outcomes in a fast-moving world where the situation on the ground—or at sea—can shift overnight.

To capitalize on these advantages, it's essential to understand the specific technologies driving this adaptability and how they are transforming supply chain management.

Real-Time Tracking: In the wake of the Houthi attacks, real-time tracking has become indispensable for managing shipping operations. It provides immediate visibility into the status and location of vessels, allowing companies to monitor their shipments as they navigate around affected areas. This capability enables swift adjustments to routes and schedules, minimizing the impact of delays and enhancing the ability to respond proactively to emerging threats.

Data Analysis: Advanced data analysis helps businesses understand and manage the complexities introduced by these disruptions. By analyzing data from various sources, companies can gain insights into the patterns of attacks and assess the risks associated with different routes. Predictive analytics can forecast potential disruptions and enable companies to adjust their logistics strategies accordingly. This foresight allows for better planning and decision-making in response to the changing dynamics of global shipping.

Navigating New Trade Routes: With the Red Sea increasingly perilous due to the Houthi attacks, businesses must rely on technology to efficiently navigate alternative routes. Real-time tracking and data analysis support the evaluation of new shipping paths, considering factors such as safety, cost and transit time. Technology helps businesses make informed decisions about rerouting shipments, ensuring that goods continue to reach their destinations despite the disruptions.

Optimizing Inventory Management: The increased transit times and costs associated with avoiding high-risk areas necessitate effective inventory management. Technology enables businesses to monitor inventory levels across multiple locations and adjust stock levels based on extended shipping times. Automated systems can optimize inventory distribution, reducing the risk of stockouts and overstocking and ensuring that supply chain operations remain efficient despite the longer delivery times.

Efficient Rerouting: In response to the Houthi attacks, efficient rerouting of shipments is critical. Data analysis tools can evaluate various routing options, helping companies identify the most effective and cost-efficient routes. This capability is essential for adapting to the increased risks and complexities of navigating around affected regions, allowing businesses to minimize disruptions and maintain operational continuity.

The recent attacks on global shipping routes have exposed the vulnerabilities of modern maritime trade. The ongoing instability impacts shipping efficiency and has broader economic implications across Asia, the Middle East and Europe. These disruptions highlight the need for adaptive supply chain strategies and leveraging advanced technologies to navigate increased risks and operational costs. Swift adaptation to evolving threats will be crucial for the resilience and success of global supply chains.

Latest