Create a free Supply & Demand Chain Executive account to continue reading

Tackling Modern Slavery: From Compliance to Measurable Impact

81% of leaders say they are genuinely committed to eliminating modern slavery from their supply chains.

Marina M Headshot
Two construction workers pushing a red wheelbarrow on a dirt site with an unfinished building under scaffolding in the background
AungMyo AdobeStock_220968476

A new BSI and CIPS study reveals that while 95% of business leaders identify modern slavery violations in their organizations, only 39% can demonstrate the actual impact of their interventions, showing a critical gap between taking action and proving meaningful change for vulnerable workers.

  • 95% of business leaders identified modern slavery violations within the last 12 months, yet only 39% can evidence the impact of their risk assessments.
  • 80% of firms believe their supply chains are slavery-free, but only 22% have comprehensive visibility of third-party suppliers.
  • 62-76% lack adequate visibility across supply chain tiers, with visibility decreasing from Tier 1 (62% partial/minimal) to Tier 3 and beyond (76% partial/minimal).
  • 56-61% of companies conducting supplier training, audits, or corrective actions cannot evidence or measure the impact of these interventions.
  • 57% lack clear internal ownership of modern slavery as an organizational issue, and only 31% have terminated supplier contracts in response to violations.

New research commissioned by BSI with a report co-created with CIPS, Slavery-free: confidence isn’t enough, the evidence matters, finds that almost all (95%) business leaders said their organizations identified modern slavery violations within the last 12 months.

Yet while the vast majority carry out modern slavery risk assessments, only 39% can evidence the impact of them.

“These findings clearly demonstrate that organizations are proactively looking for modern slavery risks and finding some of them. The challenge is then being able to demonstrate impact and show that these interventions are improving outcomes for workers. Addressing modern slavery risk is about driving meaningful change,” says Harold Pradal, president, assurance services at BSI. “As regulatory expectations continue to evolve, organizations need to move beyond compliance-led approaches and focus on measuring outcomes, strengthening supplier visibility and building greater transparency and trust. The challenge is no longer whether businesses are taking action, but whether they can demonstrate that their action is driving real improvements for vulnerable workers.”

Key takeaways:

 

·       81% of leaders say they are genuinely committed to eliminating modern slavery from their supply chains.

·       Most also express confidence that their compliance and due diligence programs meet requirements, with 71% of leaders extremely or very confident their practices would comply with anticipated future legislation.

  • Four in five (80%) believe they have sufficient evidence to demonstrate their supply chains are free from modern slavery, but only 22% report having comprehensive visibility of third-party suppliers.
  • 56% of firms carrying out supplier training on labour rights say they can’t evidence impact or haven’t sought to measure it.
  • Three in five firms (61%) that carry out unannounced supplier audits can’t evidence impact (53%) or don’t measure it (8%).
  • More than one-quarter (28%) lack the resources to conduct assessments beyond Tier 1.
  • Only 42% can evidence impact from their social auditing of suppliers.
  • 55% of those undertaking corrective action plans following audit findings can’t evidence impact or haven’t sought to measure it.
  • Less than one in three (31%) has terminated a contract with a supplier in response to identifying modern slavery.
  • Three fifths (62%) describe their visibility of social risks at Tier 1 of their supply chain as partial or minimal, but this rises to 73% for Tier 2 and 76% for Tier 3 and beyond. More than one in four say their sub-tier suppliers are unknown to them (26%).
  • Low visibility is down to regular change in supply chains (29%), suppliers providing unreliable or incomplete information (28%) or being unwilling to share information (28%), although more than one-fifth admit it is simply not a priority (22%). Business leaders also indicated they weren’t always sure what to prioritize to drive meaningful change, with many citing challenges across audit consistency, internal resources, data quality, technology and regulation. And 57% said they lacked clear internal ownership of modern slavery as an issue. The report makes clear that knowing what to prioritize can be a challenge, with businesses struggling to identify where effort can be directed.
  • Having identified modern slavery instances, 53% chose to work with suppliers to address issues rather than terminate contracts immediately, reflecting a focus on long-term improvement but stopping short of fully resolving the issue, while one in 10 (11%) say their response to identifying an issue was limited.
  • More than three-quarters (77%) are extremely or very confident their evidence base would satisfy a regulatory inspection or enforcement action, or that their approach would withstand scrutiny from litigation funders or legal challenge (77%) or withstand scrutiny from investigative media (77%). And despite having admitted to poor visibility, 75% were extremely or very confident their data accurately reflected conditions across their supply chain.
Page 1 of 32
Next Page