
Nearly 31% of online shoppers commit returns fraud by substituting items or making false claims, with 78% of U.S. retailers reporting returns fraud as a significant business problem during peak shopping seasons like Black Friday. Retailers can combat this by using technology to assess return risk and flag suspicious activity while maintaining a frictionless experience for legitimate customers.
- 31% of online shoppers admit to substituting original items with something else when making returns
- 62% of retailers most commonly encounter false claims that goods have not arrived or are damaged
- 54% of retailers report customers returning different or damaged items, while 38% deal with wardrobing—wearing clothing then returning it
- 78% of U.S. retailers say returns fraud and abuse is a significant problem for their business
- Technology solutions can flag suspicious returns and delay refunds for high-risk cases while processing legitimate returns normally
Nearly 31% of online U.S. shoppers admit to substituting the original item with something else when making a return, according to research released by Loop.
With the lead up to peak season shopping only a few weeks away, 78% of U.S. retailers say returns fraud and abuse is a problem for their business.
“Black Friday and Christmas sales figures only tell half the story. A sale that looks like a win at checkout can become a loss if a dishonest refund claim goes through or the wrong item comes back to the warehouse. As it does every year, the peak shopping period will trigger a surge in returns, so retailers face the challenge of identifying fraudulent claims without slowing down refunds for genuine customers. Increasingly, technology is being used to assess the risk of individual returns, flagging suspicious activity and delaying refunds in higher-risk cases until items have been received and inspected, while allowing legitimate returns to be processed as normal. However, treating every customer with suspicion is not the answer. Retailers need to identify abuse while keeping returns easy for honest shoppers. Otherwise, they risk losing both the money and the customer,” says Samir Kamnani, senior international program manager at Loop.
Key takeaways:
· False claims that goods have not arrived or are damaged are the most commonly encountered form of returns fraud and abuse, cited by 62% of U.S. retailers.
· Two in five (54%) commonly encounter customers returning different or damaged items, while one-third (38%) report “wardrobing,” the term for wearing clothing and then returning it.




















