Negotiating to Avoid Risk

Contract negotiation is the first line of defense to manage, mitigate and allocate the risks inherent in your supply chain when suppliers have financial problems


Even if you weather uncertain economic times, what if your suppliers do not? As companies have successfully reduced inventory and more tightly controlled their supply chain they have relied ever more on sole-sourced, just-in-time inventory management. As all companies, including your suppliers, struggle to succeed, what if that sole-sourced, just-in-time inventory does not arrive? Any supplier with whom you contract can bring your production to a halt simply by not delivering their product. Without managing, mitigating and allocating this risk, even the best run company can be brought to its knees by one failing supplier.

Protect yourself from these contingencies. Negotiate protections against this risk into your contracts. Be leery of boiler plate provisions, know how to allocate the risks inherent in a supply chain, and pay special attention to those provisions that raise the brightest red flags.

Boiler plate

Every purchasing manager and every lawyer has form contracts. Where people run into trouble is when they consider these forms to be the ending point, not the starting point. Look into your desk and the chances are that the form contract you use could be years old. It may not reflect changes in your business, the law, or other realities of the market place. Boiler plate is a great place to start, but you need to consider each supply contract to be potentially unique.

When you rely on boiler plate contracts as an ending point, you are bound to run into a number of problems. First, superfluous provisions inapplicable to the relationship create confusion. These extra provisions can create ambiguity and uncertainty which lead to delays and excess cost when trying to enforce your contractual rights. Second, the one size fits all language of boiler plate does not take into account which party might have the money, property or overall leverage if a supplier does run into financial trouble. For example, does the supplier or the purchaser own the tooling at issue? That tooling could be more important than any individual product supplied and how the tooling is handled is bound to differ supplier to supplier. Lastly, it is best to consider whether any specialized provisions need to be included for certain suppliers. This could include provisions about ownership of and rights to intellectual property, or antitrust issues related to pricing. Relying on boiler plate contracts, or the last contract you signed, as an ending point instead of a starting point is bound to result in missed ways to mitigate the risks and uncertainty created when your supplier has financial problems.

Allocating your risk

Once you recognize that you need to rely on your boiler plate only as a starting point, you can better start to tailor contracts to allocate the risks inherent in each of them. This is done principally through insurance, indemnification, and limitations.

With margins thin and profits down, one moderate liability or unexpected loss can push a supplier over the brink, not to mention the purchaser. Require suppliers to have not only commercial general liability insurance, but other insurance to protect them (and you) from losses. Requiring suppliers to have adequate property, workers compensation, umbrella, and other routine insurance helps to mitigate your own risk. For much of that insurance coverage, you can require that you be added as an additional insured. Similarly, require general and specific indemnifications from your suppliers to properly allocate risks associated with their product to them, and their insurance. Consider what you need to be indemnified for, who controls the settlement of any indemnified claim and who gets to pick counsel. Again, not negotiating such uncertainties is bound to lead to confusion and risk. For your limitations, negotiate liability and remedy limitations. These are separate and distinct and you want clarity for both parties so that they know what risks they have to protect against, indemnify and insure.

Red flags

This content continues onto the next page...
  • Enhance Your Experience.

    When you register for SDCExec.com you stay connected to the pulse of the industry by signing up for topic-based e-newsletters and information. Registering also allows you to quickly comment on content and request more infomation.

Already have an account? Click here to Log in.

Enhance Your Experience.

When you register for SDCExec.com you stay connected to the pulse of the industry by signing up for topic-based e-newsletters and information. Registering also allows you to quickly comment on content and request more infomation.

OR

Complete the registration form.

Required
Required
Required
Required
Required
Required
Required
Required
Required
Required
Required